23 Thanksgiving Desserts Beyond Pumpkin Pie

Thanksgiving Desserts Beyond Pumpkin Pie

Changing up the Thanksgiving dish is fun, and your guests will be impressed. While we are not giving up completely on pumpkin pie, there are just so many ways you can incorporate your favorite dessert into the Thanksgiving menu, and works as a last-minute dinner recipe.

Our collection of Thanksgiving desserts has so many tasty options; some traditional desserts can complement any dish effortlessly. It won’t be a holiday gathering if there is none of the amazing desserts we have compiled on the list.

Whether you are the host or the guest tasked with bringing Thanksgiving desserts, do not worry; we have you covered on delicious desserts beyond pumpkin pie.

15 Thanksgiving Desserts Beyond Pumpkin Pie

The protagonist of every Thanksgiving is pumpkin pie and it is the most versatile winter vegetable, it has two different textures that make it incredibly delicious and fitting for the holiday. However, if you are looking to try something new, and savory and can easily set a tradition? We have the perfect desserts beyond pumpkin pie below.

1. Turkey Cake

Turkey Cake
Image: Beyond Frosting

Turkey cake is an out-of-the-box thinking recipe for Thanksgiving. It is not only an exciting meal choice but a very delicious and snacky treat you can consider offering to you guest to your guests.

Get the turkey cake recipe

2. Cranberry Pumpkin Seed Toffee

Pumpkin Seed Toffee
Image: Food Fanatic

No doubt about the fact that this sumptuous treat can also be best served for Thanksgiving.

Get the Cranberry Pumpkin Seed Toffee recipe

3. Chocoflan

Image: Bake from Scratch Magazine

Chocoflan can be a delicious and unique treat to serve for Thanksgiving. The chocolate cake and creamy flan recipe is a crowd-pleaser for those who enjoy a rich and decadent dessert.

Get the chocoflan recipe

4. No-Bake Banana Caramel Pecan Pie

Best No-Bake Banana Caramel Pecan Pie
Image: Delish

No-bake banana caramel pecan pie is a delicious and easy dessert option for Thanksgiving. It features a combination of sweet bananas, rich caramel, and crunchy pecans, all without the need for baking.

Get the No-Bake Banana Caramel Pecan Pie recipe

5. Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Cookies

Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Cookies
Image: Sally’s Baking Addiction

Pumpkin chocolate chip cookies are a popular and delicious treat, especially during Thanksgiving. The soft and chewy texture of these cookies with the added warmth of pumpkin spice makes them a hit with pumpkin and chocolate lovers alike.

Get the Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Cookies recipe

6. Mini Piecakens

Amaretti Cookies
Image: Confessions of a Baking Queen

Mini Piecakens is a fun and creative twist on Thanksgiving desserts. They will make a great addition to your Thanksgiving dessert menu and offer a delicious alternative to traditional pies everyone is used to.

Get the Mini Piecakens recipe

7. Brown Butter Chocolate Blondies

Brown Butter Pumpkin Blondies
Image: Half Baked Harvest

The rich and buttery flavor of the blondies seasoned with chocolatey goodness can be a delightful and satisfying dessert option for the holiday.

Get the Brown Butter Chocolate Blondies recipe

8. Spice Chocolate Chip Biscotti

If you and your guests love a delightful and aromatic treat with the warmth of spices and the richness of chocolate chips, then here is a great Thanksgiving dessert choice for you.

Get the Spice Chocolate Chip Biscotti recipe

9. Apple Cider Donuts

Apple cider donuts
Source: Damn Delicious

Donuts can’t go wrong as Thanksgiving desserts. If you are going to make donuts, you might just as well try this warm, deliciously soft fresh donut that is coated in cinnamon sugar. Once your family and friends take a bite of these donuts, they practically will be coming back for more.

Even if you are not a donut person, you just might fall in love with this as it melts with every bite. This sugary apple cider donut recipe is one of the favorite dessert recipes and can also quickly become your favorite snack.

Get the apple cider donuts recipe.

10. Sweet Potato Pocket Pie

Sweet Potato Pocket Pie
Source: Homebody Eats

Pocket pies are super delicious and they made an awesome addition to the dessert table since they are individual portions. This amazing recipe is made with a homemade blend of chai pies, the sweet potato also adds some interesting texture and delightful taste to this that will impress anyone. This has the perfect size for anyone.

Get the sweet pocket pies recipe.

11. Orange Basque Cheesecake

Orange Basque Cheesecake
Source: Tasha’s Artisan Foods

Orange Basque Cheesecake is another dessert that can complement any Thanksgiving dish and it has a fresh beautiful flavor anyone would love. This Basque cheesecake is made with caramelized oranges and a nearly burnt top matching the velvety crumb and orange zest. This recipe will fill your kitchen with the most irresistible scent.

Get the orange basque cheesecake recipe.

Cinnamon Roll Sugar Cookie Bars
Source: Taste of the Frontier

Are you a cinnamon lover? This Cinnamon Roll Sugar Cookie bar is the perfect treat for you, it is a combination of soft and chewy sugar cookies and cinnamon that is topped with sweet cream cheesy frosting. It’s indulgent season so all the more reason to try this delicious cookie bar.

Get the cinnamon roll sugar cookie bars recipe.

13. Hoosier Sugar Cream Pie

Hoosier Sugar Cream Pie
Source: Saving Room for Dessert

If you are not so down for the cinnamon sugar cream pie then this simple Hoosier sugar cookie pie is another perfect choice. This sugar cream pie is also known as Hoosier or Indiana Sugar Cream Pie.

There is no egg used in making this and it’s an old-fashioned cookie pie that has been around since the 1800s this is even more wonderful with its impossibly silky filling and broiled cinnamon topping.

Get the Hoosier sugar cream pie recipe.

14. Amish Apple Fritter Bread

Amish Apple Fritter Bread
Source: I Wash You Dry

You can always opt for something crispy and with a sweet vanilla flavor which is this Amish Apple Fritter Bread. This dessert is made with fresh apples hence it’s packed with tart apple flavor, and cinnamon, and topped with a sweet brown sugar topping. This can be found in the Amish bakery Midwest and you can make them.

Get the Amish apple fritter bread recipe.

15. Mini Butterfinger Bundt Cake

Mini Butterfinger bundt cake
Source: Butterfinger

Butterfinger bundt cake will have your dinner guests coming back for more. If you are a fan of Butterfinger candy bars then there is no doubt that you would love this mini Butterfinger bundt cake recipe, this delicious cake will make your mouth water and become your family’s favorite in no time.

Get the mini butterfingers bundt cake recipe.

16. Lemon Cranberry Cheesecake Bars

Lemon Cranberry Cheesecake Bars
Source: Delish.com

Lemon Cranberry Cheesecake Bars have sweet, tart, tangy, and cheesecake bars. Something about the combo taste of this dessert and thanks to the extra sweetness and creamy filling. This comes with a super easy and irresistible cranberry filling and some amazing spice combos have been snuck in it to add a cozy touch to it.

Get the lemon cranberry cheesecake bars recipe.

17. Chocolate Citrus Chocoflan

Chocolate Citrus Chocoflan
Source: Bake from Scratch

This is a beautiful contrasting layer of chocolate cake and flan, it’s not only beautiful but delicious. This is a showstopping and mind-blowing cake, the shape takes place before the flan set and while the cake batter aerates. There is also an addition of espresso powder and a splash of coffee liqueur, giving the cake a bold layer of bright cocoa flavor.

Get the chocolate citrus chocolate recipe.

18. Passion Fruit Ice Cream

Passion Fruit Ice Cream
Source: Bakes by Brown Sugar

Passion Fruit Ice Cream can have you singing in joy at the end of the Thanksgiving dinner. This seasonal dessert is a creamy combination of passion tart and ice cream.

The passion fruit has its unique flavor that adds a beautiful floral aroma to any dessert while the ice cream adds some incredible addition to the flavor. This is only made with four ingredients.

Get the passion fruit ice cream recipe.

19. Pumpkin Cheesecake

Pumpkin Cheesecake
Source: Handle the Heat

You don’t have to stop for dessert for your dinner on Thanksgiving if all you have is pumpkins. You can make this delicious pumpkin cheesecake which is creamy, smooth rich, and indulgent. This cheesecake is made with a Biscoff cookie crust and topped with homemade whipped cream. This is a perfect Thanksgiving dessert your family is going to love.

Get the pumpkin cheesecake recipe.

20. Cranberry Trifle

Cranberry Trifle
Source: Spend with Pennies

Cranberry trifle is a soft-layered cake made with sweet-tart cranberries and creamy homemade custard. Trifles are best made ahead and it has a balance of flavor that will have your guests and family coming back for more. This beautiful cranberry is perfect for any time of the year.

Get the cranberry trifle recipe.

21. Baked Churro Chips

Baked Churro Chips
Source: Simply Scrumptious Eats

Looking for healthy baked chips you can make in the comfort of your home? These churro chips are so easy to make and they are made using raw tortillas. They happen to pair so well with your end-of-feast espresso and they are pretty popular for Thanksgiving.

Get the baked churro chips recipe.

22. Guinness Chocolate Cake

guinness cake

Guinness Chocolate Cake is one of the greatest dessert combos that works for Thanksgiving. This can easily become your favorite go-to dessert, it is made with reduced dark stout beer to give it a deep flavor and then topped with ultra creamy chocolate Guinness cream cheese frosting. This cake is proof that chocolate and stout make the perfect dessert combo.

Get the Guinness chocolate cake recipe.

23. Old Fashioned Apple Dumplings

Old Fashioned Apple Dumplings
Source: Num’s the Word

These old-fashioned Apple Dumplings are super warming and perfect for a Thanksgiving treat. You can try these apple dumplings in your home for a cozy weeknight of comfort. This recipe is a huge hit during the cold and holiday seasons.

This also comes out gooey and the crisp apples melt into your flaky crust, the whole thing is also drizzled with the sweetest cinnamon syrup.

Get the old-fashioned apple dumplings recipe.

Final Thoughts

There are many ways to incorporate your favorite ingredient into Thanksgiving dessert, so it does not have to be all around pumpkins alone. Pumpkin pies will always be a hit, but the desserts above are another gooey treat you must try.

From, Cheesecakes, to Brownies and Apple Cider Donuts to the Amish Apple Fritter Bread, these are classics that come in handy when you need to try something new. They are almost too good to eat, you may never return to lackluster pie again!

Was this article helpful?
Previous Article
Pork Loin Filet Recipes For Enthusiasts

21 Pork Loin Filet Recipes For Enthusiasts (2024)

Next Article
Halloween-themed Cocktails and Drinks

18 Halloween-themed Cocktails and Drinks (2024)

Related Posts